Progressive Customers in Colorado Whose Totaled Cars Were Valued With a Disputed Discount Can Claim From a $15.2 Million Settlement by Feb. 5
When Progressive declared a Colorado driver’s car a total loss, the payout was built on a valuation report that compared the car with similar ones for sale. A class action says one line in that report shaved money off the check, and Progressive has now agreed to pay part of it back.
Under a proposed settlement in Curran v. Progressive Direct Insurance Co., about $15.2 million is available to Colorado customers whose totaled cars were valued with that deduction. The court-approved class notice says total payments available are approximately $15,240,887, and claims must be filed online or postmarked by Feb. 5, 2027.
The “Projected Sold Adjustment” at the Center of the Case
The deduction is called a projected sold adjustment, or PSA. It appears in Mitchell Instant Reports, the valuation reports Progressive used to price totaled cars against comparable vehicles, and it was applied to the comparison cars in the reports at issue.
The notice says the plaintiffs claim Progressive “systematically paid its insureds less than the actual cash value of their vehicles for total loss claims” by relying on Mitchell valuation reports that applied these adjustments, “which Plaintiffs allege are improper.”
Progressive does not agree. The settlement agreement, dated June 29, 2026, says the companies “deny and continue to deny all material allegations” and are settling without admitting liability. That is why the deduction is a disputed one: the drivers say it was wrong, and the insurer says it was not.
Which Colorado Customers Qualify
The settlement covers two groups, split by which Progressive company issued the policy. According to the class notice, a person qualifies if all of these are true:
- The personal auto policy was issued to a Colorado resident by Progressive Direct Insurance Company or Progressive Preferred Insurance Company.
- The driver made a first-party property damage claim, and Progressive declared the vehicle a total loss.
- The payment was based on a Mitchell Instant Report that applied a projected sold adjustment to at least one comparable vehicle.
- For Progressive Direct, the claim was submitted from April 12, 2019, through July 8, 2026. For Progressive Preferred, the window runs from Dec. 19, 2021, through July 8, 2026.
The agreement estimates about $12.51 million is available to the Progressive Direct group and about $2.73 million to the Progressive Preferred group.
How Much a Totaled Car Could Bring Back
There is no flat payment. Each check is a share of the car’s value, figured from Progressive’s own records.
The notice sets the “PSA Impact Amount” at 2.75% of the vehicle’s actual cash value for the Direct group and 2.25% for the Preferred group. Progressive pays 68% of that amount to each person who files a valid claim. That works out to roughly 1.87% of the car’s value for Direct customers and about 1.53% for Preferred customers.
By that formula, a car valued at $20,000 would bring about $374 for a Direct customer and about $306 for a Preferred customer. AllAboutLawyer’s worked examples put a $35,000 car at about $655 for Direct and $536 for Preferred. Those figures are estimates from the formula, not official amounts.
Lawyers’ fees do not come out of those payments. The agreement says class counsel may ask for up to $4,572,199 in fees and $200,000 in costs, paid separately by Progressive.
Feb. 5 Deadline and a January Hearing
The money is not automatic. The fund is claims-made, so Progressive pays only approved claims, and anyone who does not file gets nothing. The deadlines, according to the notice:
- Nov. 5, 2026: last day to opt out or object (passed)
- Jan. 6, 2027: fairness hearing at 10 a.m. in Courtroom A641 of the federal courthouse in Denver
- Feb. 5, 2027: claims due online by 11:59 p.m. Eastern, or by mail postmarked that day
Questions go to the settlement administrator at 1-888-808-1463, the number printed on the mailed notice. Mailed claims go to the Curran v. Progressive Settlement Administrator, P.O. Box 301132, Los Angeles, CA 90030-1132. ClaimDepot lists the case as No. 1:22-cv-00878 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado.
Because the opt-out deadline has passed, Colorado customers who fit the class are bound by the deal whether or not they file. Once the court enters final judgment, class members release claims arising out of Progressive’s settlement of a total loss claim, the agreement says.
Some claims are carved out. Personal injury, medical payments and uninsured or underinsured motorist claims are not part of the release, so a driver with an injury claim from the same crash keeps it.
When the Checks Would Go Out
Payments wait for the judge. Under the agreement, Progressive must fund approved claims within 30 days after the settlement takes effect, and the administrator must send payments within 60 days after that money arrives. Any appeal would push both dates back.
Checks are the default. Claimants who want an electronic payment can choose one on the claim form. Paper checks are good for 180 days, and money from uncashed checks goes back to Progressive, so a check that sits in a drawer is lost.
Colorado drivers are not the only ones seeing insurers pay over how claims were handled. In Washington, State Farm customers whose cars were fixed under underinsured motorist coverage can claim about $625 by Dec. 14.
For Progressive customers in Colorado, the key dates are fixed for now: the hearing on Jan. 6 and the claim deadline on Feb. 5. The notice warns that the court can change the hearing date or time without further notice.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Ken Lund from Reno, Nevada, USA – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons
