About 4.3 Million Medicare Members Lose Their Plan on Dec. 31, Including 950,000 in SilverScript Choice. Open Enrollment Ends Dec. 7.
By Dec. 7, about 4.3 million Medicare members whose plans end on Dec. 31 need to pick a replacement during open enrollment, according to a KFF analysis published Oct. 27. The group includes 950,000 people in CVS Health’s SilverScript Choice, a stand-alone drug plan. Open enrollment began Oct. 15 and closes Dec. 7, 2026, per the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
Plans were required to send non-renewal notices in early October, Medical Daily reported, so many members have already received one. Anyone who has not read it yet still has days left to act.
The 4.3 million plans that stop on Dec. 31
KFF counted 4.3 million Medicare beneficiaries whose Medicare Advantage or stand-alone Part D plan is terminated at the end of 2026. Of those, 3.1 million are in Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage and 1.2 million are in stand-alone drug plans. A separate 1.4 million Medicare Advantage members sit in plans that are consolidating into another plan from the same insurer.
The stand-alone number is dominated by one product. KFF reports SilverScript Choice accounts for 950,000 of the 1.2 million, or 81%, and ends in 13 regions. HealthSpring Extra Rx, from Health Care Service Corporation, accounts for another 190,000 in 16 regions. The analysis notes that 6% of all stand-alone drug plan enrollees are affected, double the 3% share the year before.
Insurers and regions behind the cuts
On the Medicare Advantage side, KFF found Humana has the largest share of affected members at 530,000, followed by UnitedHealth Group at 367,000 and CVS Health at 254,000. Aware Integrated, which sells Blue Cross plans in Minnesota, has 249,000. About 2.8 million of the Medicare Advantage members are in plans open to general enrollment, and roughly 300,000 are in special needs plans.
Where a member lives decides the outcome. Medical Daily reported that SilverScript Choice leaves 13 of Medicare’s 34 drug plan regions, so the plan continues in the rest. Aetna said in an Oct. 3 release that it will keep offering SilverScript Choice for 2027, with $0 Tier 1 drug copays, and that enrollment depends on contract renewal. A member in an ending region should rely on the notice sent for that specific plan.
Steps before open enrollment closes
KFF says Medicare Advantage members should enroll in another Medicare Advantage plan if one is offered in their area. Stand-alone drug plan members must choose a new drug plan, or move to a Medicare Advantage plan with drug coverage, to keep Part D. Members of a consolidating plan are moved automatically to the insurer’s other plan, KFF said, though they can pick a different plan during open enrollment.
CMS points to the Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov for comparing premiums, benefits and costs, and to 1-800-MEDICARE, which runs around the clock. Medical Daily advised keeping the non-renewal notice and listing every prescription, dose and pharmacy before comparing plans, and checking each drug’s formulary status and pharmacy network.
Free local counseling is another route. The State Health Insurance Assistance Programs connect people with one-on-one Medicare counselors, and the program’s number is 877-839-2675. CMS also says people with limited income may qualify for Extra Help or Medicare Savings Programs, which lower costs.
What replacement plans cost
CMS projects the average monthly premium for a stand-alone drug plan will rise by less than $1, from $35.09 in 2026 to $36 in 2027. The agency says about 88% of beneficiaries who are not low-income can find a basic plan at $10.30 or less a month, and 93% can find an enhanced plan under $6.
For Medicare Advantage, CMS projects the weighted average premium falling from $14.37 to $12.00. It says more than 99% of beneficiaries can reach at least one Medicare Advantage plan and 97% can reach 10 or more, which gives most affected members somewhere to move. CMS adds that people who want to keep their current coverage generally do not need to re-enroll, a line that does not apply to members whose plan is ending.
Aetna’s release says its Medicare Advantage drug plans are offered in 41 states plus Washington, D.C., and that all of them have $0 Tier 1 drug copays at preferred pharmacies. Aetna gives a toll-free line for questions, 1-844-588-0041, open daily from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.
The Dec. 8 to February window
Missing Dec. 7 does not end the options. For plans that are not renewed, Medicare.gov lists a special enrollment period that runs from Dec. 8 through the last day of February. Members can switch to another Medicare Advantage plan or drug plan in that window.
Waiting carries costs. Medicare.gov says a member who does not join another Medicare Advantage plan before the old one ends is enrolled in Original Medicare. KFF adds that people whose Medicare Advantage coverage is terminated also get a special enrollment period to buy a Medigap policy with protections that bar insurers from denying coverage or charging more over a pre-existing condition. A stand-alone drug plan member who takes no step risks starting January without Part D drug coverage.
Medical Daily noted that people who receive Extra Help are placed in a new drug plan automatically if they do not choose one by Dec. 31.
The site has also covered the average Medicare Advantage premium for 2027 and the Part D out-of-pocket cap.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: U.S. Air Force photo by Airman 1st Class Karina Lopez – Public domain/Wikimedia Commons
