Southbound Interstate 5 traffic seen from NE 45th Street in Seattle, Washington
SounderBruce - CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Washington State Farm Customers Whose Cars Were Fixed Under Underinsured Motorist Coverage Can Claim About $625 by Dec. 14

A repaired car is rarely worth what it was before the crash, even when the body shop does flawless work. A buyer who sees a frame repair on a vehicle history report pays less. A lawsuit against State Farm argued that Washington policyholders were owed that lost value, and the settlement that came out of it is now taking claims.

The settlement in Hardy v. State Farm sets aside up to $8,822,039.83 for Washington drivers whose vehicles were repaired under State Farm’s underinsured motorist property damage coverage. The claims administrator estimates an average payment of about $625, and claims are due Dec. 14, 2026, according to the settlement summary from Open Class Actions.

What the Lawsuit Was About

Underinsured motorist property damage coverage, often shortened to UMPD, pays for damage to a policyholder’s own car when the at-fault driver has no insurance or not enough of it. Washington’s Office of the Insurance Commissioner explains how that coverage works for drivers hit by an uninsured or underinsured driver on its auto insurance resource page.

Tyler Hardy and Jermine Santiago filed suit in January 2025 in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington. They claimed State Farm failed to pay diminished value under that coverage, which AllAboutLawyer describes as “the loss in a vehicle’s market value that can remain even after quality repairs,” in its summary of the case.

State Farm denies wrongdoing and agreed to settle. The case number is 2:25-cv-00072-RSM, before Judge Ricardo S. Martinez. The court granted preliminary approval in June 2026, which is what opened the claim window. Class counsel are the Law Offices of Stephen M. Hansen and Nealey Law.

Who Qualifies for a Payment

The class is narrow, and every condition has to be met. According to Top Class Actions, a policyholder qualifies if:

  • They were a State Farm insured with a Washington-issued policy.
  • State Farm paid for their vehicle’s damage under UMPD coverage, for an accident between Jan. 13, 2019 and Feb. 27, 2026.
  • The repair estimate, including supplements, was at least $1,000.
  • The vehicle was no more than six years old, counted as model year plus five, and had fewer than 90,000 miles at the time of the accident.
  • The vehicle had structural or frame damage, deformed sheet metal, or needed body or paint work.

Leased vehicles and cars declared a total loss are excluded. Claims for only glass, tires or a sound system do not count. A policyholder with more than one qualifying accident must file a separate claim for each one.

AllAboutLawyer points out two details that trip people up. The $1,000 test is based on the repair estimate, not on what the driver paid out of pocket, so a policyholder with a small deductible can still qualify. And as its summary puts it, “Meeting one requirement alone is not enough”: a newer car with a large estimate still has to show structural, sheet metal, or body and paint damage.

How the $625 Estimate Works

The $625 figure is an average, not a fixed check. Claim Depot’s settlement page says payments are pro rata, based on each claimant’s repair costs compared with everyone else’s. A larger repair bill means a larger share.

Anyone who already received a diminished value payment from State Farm for the same accident will get a reduced amount. Payments go out by paper check.

The fund pays legal costs first. Claim Depot lists up to $1,852,628 plus costs for attorneys’ fees, which AllAboutLawyer puts at up to 21% of the fund, and $10,000 service awards for each of the two named plaintiffs. State Farm pays the cost of running the settlement separately, and the rest goes to drivers who file valid claims. If valid claims add up to more than the fund, every payment is reduced proportionally.

How to File Before Dec. 14

Claims can be filed online or by a paper form postmarked by Dec. 14, 2026. Online filing requires the Class Member ID printed on the mailed notice. The administrator is Kroll Settlement Administration LLC, P.O. Box 225391, New York, NY 10150-5391, which can be reached at 833-930-0261.

The deadline to opt out or object passed on Sept. 30, and the court held its final approval hearing on Oct. 30. Claim Depot notes that payments will be sent only after final approval and the end of any appeals, so a check will not arrive before the claim window closes.

For a Washington driver who was hit by an uninsured or underinsured motorist since January 2019 and had a newer car repaired through State Farm, the step is to find the notice, confirm the repair met the $1,000 and age-and-mileage tests, and file by Dec. 14. Drivers who did not get a notice but believe they qualify can contact the administrator at the number above.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: SounderBruce – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *