An electronic message sign over the New Jersey Turnpike
ActivBowser9177 - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

GEICO Returned More Than $10.5 Million to Over 15,000 New Jersey Customers After the State Found It Overcharged Them for Car Insurance

Thousands of GEICO customers in New Jersey paid more for car insurance than they should have, and the company has now handed that money back. A state exam found GEICO billed some drivers above approved rates and moved others into pricier coverage by mistake.

The New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance announced on Oct. 20 that its enforcement action recovered more than $10.5 million in wrongfully charged premium for New Jersey policyholders. The department said the problems touched more than 15,000 policyholders across several GEICO companies, and that GEICO began issuing refunds on its own during the examination as errors turned up.

The Three Billing Mistakes Behind the Money

The department’s examiners reviewed GEICO’s private passenger auto business from June 1, 2023, to May 31, 2024, after consumer complaints. Their market conduct examination report, adopted on Oct. 20, breaks the refunds into three groups:

  • Accident forgiveness: 4,662 policies were moved to a different GEICO company in error, 33% of the 14,123 the examiners looked at. Refunds and credits after the exam began came to $6,744,192.26.
  • “Lending losses”: 2,251 policies, or 16% of 14,362, were moved in error. Refunds and credits came to about $1.76 million, including $1,755,083.20 after the exam started.
  • Rate capping: 9,714 policies needed refunds out of 12,605 affected, totaling $2,076,482.50.

Those three groups add up to roughly the $10.5 million the department announced.

How Accident Forgiveness Ended Up Costing More

The biggest share of the money traces back to accident forgiveness, the benefit GEICO sold to soften the price impact of an accident. According to News 12 New Jersey, examiners found GEICO misapplied those benefits and also labeled some accidents involving other drivers as lending losses. Both mistakes shifted policyholders from one GEICO affiliate to another and raised their premiums.

The rate-capping problem was separate. Errors in GEICO’s rate-capping system caused about $2.08 million in refunds, the station reported. In the examiners’ count, more than three of every four rate-capped policies they flagged, 9,714 of 12,605, ended up owed money.

The department listed four broad problem areas in its announcement:

  • charging rates higher than what the department had approved
  • canceling policies for improper reasons
  • leaving required language off notices that could lead to a policy not being renewed
  • failing to tell owners who kept a totaled vehicle about their rights

The report counted 49 policies canceled after the first 60 days using language that only applies during the first 60 days. It also flagged smaller groups of cancellations tied to ridesharing, food and goods delivery, and a claim loss.

Two Years From Complaint to Refund

The case took a long road. The department said its examination began in September 2024, after consumers complained. The report describes the exam as of Oct. 9, 2025, and the examiner in charge signed off on it on Feb. 27, 2026. The department adopted it on Oct. 20, the same day it announced the penalty.

Along the way, GEICO ran its own checks on samples the examiners pulled. Those self-audits turned up more money owed: $65,103.73 on 50 of 274 lending-loss policies, and $10,813.58 on 26 of 260 accident-forgiveness policies, according to the report.

The report also told GEICO to go back through every policy hit by the three billing problems, not just the samples, and to send the department spreadsheets showing each refund or credit.

Not every finding was about premiums. The examiners also looked at personal injury protection (PIP) claims, which pay medical bills after a crash, and found at least one overdue claim that carried $67.35 in interest under state law.

Letters, Credits and a Number to Call

Most affected drivers should not have to do anything. The department’s notice to impacted GEICO policyholders says letters went directly to the people involved, their policies were adjusted, and either a credit was applied to the policy or a premium refund was issued.

The exam report also set the wording for those letters. Refund notices must tell customers that GEICO made errors in their payments or billings that were brought to its attention.

Drivers who think they were affected but never got a letter can call GEICO customer service at (800) 841-1587, the number the state lists. New Jersey’s consumer hotline, at 1-800-446-7467, also takes insurance complaints.

A $1.2 Million Penalty and a Second Look Within a Year

On top of the refunds, GEICO and its affiliates agreed to pay a $1.2 million penalty. The consent order, signed by the companies on Sept. 28 and by the department on Oct. 20, names Government Employees Insurance Company, GEICO Secure Insurance Company, GEICO Choice Insurance Company, GEICO Indemnity Company and GEICO Casualty Company.

The order requires GEICO to keep monitoring its underwriting, cancellation and claims work and to follow the report’s recommendations. The department can reexamine the company within 12 months to check that it did.

Acting Commissioner Susan Ochs said in the announcement that consumer protection sits at the heart of the department’s mission.

GEICO said in a statement that it “has already taken steps to address the department’s recommendations,” News 12 reported. Insurance Journal noted that the exam found a “systemic pattern of improper practices” and was prompted by consumer complaints.

The refunds land as New Jersey households are also seeing state money arrive. The state began mailing 467,000 Stay NJ property tax checks to seniors on Nov. 16, and ANCHOR payments of up to $1,500 are still going out.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: ActivBowser9177 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *