A T-Mobile store entrance inside Salmon Run Mall in Watertown, New York
Lallint - CC0/Wikimedia Commons

T-Mobile Must Drop the Data Cap on Its $15-a-Month Home Internet Plan for New Yorkers on SNAP or Medicaid, Under a Deal With the State

Fifty gigabytes goes fast in a house where children stream homework videos and a parent works from a laptop. New York investigators found that a typical customer on T-Mobile’s low-cost home internet plan could burn through that much in about four days, and after that the connection slowed to a crawl.

That is set to change under an agreement announced Nov. 9 by Gov. Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James. T-Mobile must remove the data cap on the $15-a-month plan it sells to income-eligible New Yorkers, deliver the 25 Mbps download speed the plan promises, and offer it everywhere the company sells home internet in the state.

The 650 Kbps Problem

New York’s Affordable Broadband Act requires internet providers to sell qualifying low-income households high-speed service for $15 a month at 25 Mbps, or $20 a month at 200 Mbps or faster. The state’s investigation, run by the Office of the Attorney General after a referral from the Department of Public Service, found T-Mobile’s version fell short.

According to the state, T-Mobile advertised its plan as 25 Mbps for $15 a month. After a customer used 50 GB in a month, the company cut download speeds by more than 97%, to 650 Kbps. At that speed, streaming video or a video call becomes difficult.

Investigators also found two other problems. T-Mobile offered the low-cost plan only where it had 5G service, even though it sold full-price 25 Mbps plans in areas covered by its 4G network. And the company had coded its low-cost plan webpage so search engines would not show it.

Neither the governor’s announcement nor the signed agreement says how many New York households are enrolled in T-Mobile’s low-cost plan today. That number will come later: the company’s compliance report must list how many state residents are on the plan and the average download speeds they actually get, giving the Attorney General a way to check whether the slowdowns have stopped.

What T-Mobile Agreed to Do, and When

The signed Assurance of Discontinuance, numbered 26-069, took effect Nov. 9 and sets deadlines counted from that date:

  • Within 60 days, T-Mobile must keep a public webpage describing its Affordable Broadband Act plans, with nothing blocking it from search results.
  • Within 120 days, it must stop intentionally slowing those customers below the law’s minimum speed, and offer the plan at every address where it sells residential fixed wireless service.
  • Within 300 days, it must file a compliance report with the Attorney General, including how many New Yorkers are enrolled and their average download speeds.

The agreement allows temporary slowdowns caused only by network congestion. It does not include a fine or customer refunds. If a court later finds T-Mobile broke the agreement, the company would owe the state’s costs of enforcing it, including legal fees.

Who Qualifies for the $15 Plan

Under the law, now part of the state’s General Business Law, a household qualifies if it is eligible for or receives any of these:

  • SNAP food benefits
  • Medicaid
  • Free or reduced-price school lunch
  • The Senior Citizen Rent Increase Exemption or Disability Rent Increase Exemption
  • HEAP or another utility affordability benefit

The governor’s office said households without those benefits may still qualify based on income. The $15 price must include recurring taxes and fees, such as equipment rental, and providers cannot require a bundle to get it.

The law also limits price increases. Providers on the $15 option can raise the price once every five years, and those on the $20 option once every two years, with 30 days’ notice. Each increase is capped at the lesser of the latest Consumer Price Index change or 2% a year. Providers with 20,000 or fewer households can ask the Public Service Commission for an exemption.

How New Yorkers Can Sign Up

The state’s broadband consumer resources page says households can call 211 for help enrolling, while New York City residents can call 311 or use AccessNYC. People can also contact providers directly. The page lists the companies offering low-cost plans county by county, including Charter, Comcast, Frontier, Optimum, Verizon, T-Mobile, Starlink and others.

The Department of Public Service also runs a broadband map that shows which providers at a given address offer a low-cost plan. The reduced-price rules cover wireline, fixed wireless and satellite home service, but not mobile phone plans.

“Reliable and affordable internet service is a basic need for all New Yorkers,” James said in the announcement, encouraging eligible households to enroll. Hochul said no New Yorker should struggle to get reliable, affordable internet, and that the state would keep holding companies accountable. Public Service Commission Chair Rory Christian thanked both offices for securing changes that affirm the law’s protections.

Other Help for the Same Households

Many of the households that qualify for the internet plan also qualify for other New York programs that lower monthly bills. This winter, New York’s heating aid is worth up to $1,086, and the state raised the base HEAP benefit for oil and propane homes to $990. Because the governor’s office lists HEAP among the qualifying benefits, a household approved for heating help also meets the eligibility test for the $15 broadband plan.

The Affordable Broadband Act also requires each provider to file an annual compliance report with the Department of Public Service by Nov. 15 covering enrollment, eligibility checks, marketing and prices. The Attorney General can seek an injunction, restitution and civil penalties of up to $1,000 per violation against providers that do not comply.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Lallint – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *