New England Utilities Owe Electric Customers About $1.5 Billion for Overcharges Dating to 2011, and Refunds Are Due by May 20, 2027
Every electric bill in New England carries a line most households never read: the cost of the high-voltage lines that move power across the region. Federal regulators have now ruled that the companies owning those lines were allowed to earn too much on them for years, and the money is supposed to come back.
The total is estimated at about $1.5 billion, according to Massachusetts Gov. Maura Healey’s office, which is pressing Eversource, National Grid and Unitil to start paying it back. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has set a firm outer deadline: refunds must be completed by May 20, 2027.
What FERC Decided in March
The case began in 2011, when the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office and a coalition of New England consumer advocates challenged the profit rate built into transmission charges. On March 19, 2026, FERC agreed that the rate had been “unjust and unreasonable.”
The Maine Office of the Public Advocate laid out the numbers in its statement on the ruling. The base return on equity set in 2011 was 11.14%. An interim rate of 10.57% had been in place since 2014. FERC replaced both with a base return of 9.57%.
Refunds, with interest, cover two stretches: Oct. 1, 2011 through Dec. 31, 2012, and Oct. 16, 2014 onward. The Maine advocate’s office said the total could top $1.5 billion and that transmission rates should fall by roughly $140 million a year going forward.
Connecticut’s Office of Consumer Counsel, speaking for the Consumer Advocates of New England, called it “a victory for New England’s ratepayers” in its March 30 release. That early release used a preliminary refund estimate of about $900 million and more than $100 million a year in savings. Later estimates from Maine’s advocate and the Healey administration put the refund near $1.5 billion once interest and the full refund periods are counted.
The Utilities Tried to Wait
The companies did not hand the money over. They asked FERC to pause the refunds while they appealed. FERC said no in May, calling a stay “an extraordinary remedy,” according to Utility Dive’s report on the denial. The utilities also asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit for a delay, and the Healey administration said that court denied it as well.
Utility Dive reported that Eversource owes about $880 million and Avangrid about $203 million. Other transmission owners in the case include Emera Maine, Green Mountain Power, Unitil, Vermont Electric Power Co., Vermont Transco and PPL’s Rhode Island Energy. Eversource said it was “disappointed” with the decision.
The companies are still arguing over the rate itself. On April 30, they asked FERC to raise the allowed return to 11.39%, Utility Dive reported. Eversource has told investors its possible pre-tax loss from the case ranges from $60.4 million to $932 million.
After the utilities and ISO New England, the region’s grid operator, asked for more time, FERC set May 20, 2027 as the date by which the refunds must be complete.
Governors and Advocates Want It Sooner
Healey’s office said in October that she had written to Eversource, National Grid and Unitil asking them to begin refunds immediately and to report by Oct. 27 how much Massachusetts customers are owed, on what schedule they will be repaid and how the money will reach them.
Advocates in every state have lined up behind the ruling. Connecticut Consumer Counsel Claire Coleman, Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell, New Hampshire Consumer Advocate Donald Kreis and Linda George, who runs Rhode Island’s Division of Public Utilities and Carriers, all praised the decision in the coalition’s release. George said her office remains focused on removing excessive charges from Rhode Islanders’ bills.
In Maine, the fight has moved to how fast the money shows up on bills. WGME reported on Nov. 12 that Central Maine Power says the federally ordered refund will appear on customer bills in 2027, while CMP is also seeking an additional $25.6 million a year in rates starting Jan. 1. The state’s Office of the Public Advocate wants refunds to begin Jan. 1 instead and said CMP’s request “makes no sense,” according to the station’s report on the dispute. CMP has until Nov. 20 to respond.
What It Means for a Household Bill
None of the agencies has published a per-household refund figure yet. The amount each customer sees will depend on the utility, the state and how the refund is spread across bills, which is exactly what Massachusetts asked the companies to spell out.
What is settled is the direction. The money is owed to electric customers across Massachusetts, Connecticut, Maine, New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Vermont, it includes interest, and FERC’s deadline for paying it is May 20, 2027. Maine’s public advocate, Heather Sanborn, said her office “will press for the refunds due to Mainers to be returned swiftly.”
The lower return also keeps paying after the refund. Maine’s advocate expects transmission costs across the region to fall by roughly $140 million a year, money that would otherwise have been built into every household’s delivery charges.
For households watching winter bills climb, the practical step is to watch for a refund or credit line on electric bills in the coming months, and for each state’s utility regulator to announce how its share will be paid.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Stefan Andrej Shambora – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons
