Cars on eastbound Interstate 4 in Florida passing under the Tomoka Farms Road overpass
Michael Rivera - CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Infinity Auto Will Refund More Than $46 Million in Excess Profits to Florida Customers Within 60 Days, the State Says

Florida drivers who had an Infinity Auto policy at the end of 2025 are owed part of the money they paid for it. The state’s insurance regulator says the company made more profit on its Florida car insurance than state law allows, and it has to send the extra back.

The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation announced on Nov. 2 that Commissioner Mike Yaworsky had secured more than $46 million in excess profits from Infinity Auto Insurance Company, covering 2023, 2024 and 2025. According to the office, Infinity will refund the money to consumers within 60 days.

Where the $46 Million Came From

Florida has a law that puts a ceiling on how much an auto insurer can earn from its policyholders. Under section 627.066 of the Florida Statutes, an insurer has made an “excessive profit” when its underwriting gain over the three most recent years tops the profit it projected, plus 5% of the premiums it earned over that stretch.

Insurers have to file the numbers with the state every year before July 1. Infinity filed its excess profits report in June and agreed not to fight the finding, waiving its right to an administrative hearing, Insurance Journal reported. The trade publication put the exact figure at $46,246,666, set out in an order dated Oct. 22.

Infinity is a Birmingham, Alabama-based insurer that sells nonstandard and specialty auto coverage, according to Insurance Journal. It is owned by Kemper. In a statement quoted by Insurance Journal, Kemper said it is “returning approximately $46.2 million to eligible Florida auto policyholders through premium credits and refunds.”

“Insurers must act in the best interest of Florida consumers,” Yaworsky said in the state’s announcement. The office also said other auto insurers are getting close to the same profit limit, a sign that more refunds may follow.

Which Infinity Customers Get a Share

The law spells out who is paid. Refunds go to the insurer’s private passenger auto policyholders of record on Dec. 31 of the last year in the calculation, which here is 2025. Each person’s share is pro rata, based on the premium that policy earned in that final year.

In plain terms, a driver who paid Infinity more in 2025 gets a larger slice than a driver who paid less. The state’s announcement and the company’s statement do not give a number of policyholders or an average refund, so the size of each check will depend on the premium on each policy.

No claim form is mentioned anywhere in the state’s announcement or the statute. The refund follows the policy, which is why Florida’s rules focus on finding people rather than asking them to apply.

Checks, Credits and the 60-Day Clock

Florida law gives insurers two ways to return excess profits: a cash refund or a credit toward a future policy. The statute’s timing rules are strict:

  • Cash refunds must be finished within 60 days of the final order. Counting 60 days from the Oct. 22 order lands on Dec. 21.
  • Credits go on renewal premium notices sent more than 60 days after the order.
  • If a policy is canceled or ends before a credit can be used, the insurer owes a cash refund within 60 days of that termination.

Insurance Journal reported that checks should be mailed within about two months. Once the refunds are done, the company has to certify to the state that it has finished paying.

The order itself is posted on the regulator’s site as a scanned PDF, alongside the Nov. 2 announcement.

Progressive’s Nearly $1 Billion Refund Came First

This is not the first time Florida’s profit cap has put money back in drivers’ pockets. In October 2025, the state announced that Progressive would return nearly $1 billion to about 2.7 million Florida auto policyholders under the same law, after the company booked a $950 million policyholder credit expense. Progressive said those credits would go to active policyholders as of Dec. 31, 2025.

Infinity’s refund is far smaller, but it works the same way. The state framed the Progressive refunds as a result of an improving insurance market, and Kemper told Insurance Journal it has already cut rates for its Florida auto customers as conditions improved after legislative reforms that it said reduced legal system abuse.

Florida households have seen a run of lower bills lately. Duke Energy Florida’s January electric bills are set to come in lower than last year, and Tampa Electric is cutting the typical home bill to $154.18 in January.

What Happens to Checks That Come Back

Moves, new addresses and closed accounts mean some refund checks will bounce back to the company. The state’s announcement says Infinity agreed to try to find policyholders whose refund checks are returned.

If the company still can’t reach someone, the money doesn’t stay with Infinity. It has to be reported and handled as unclaimed or abandoned property under Chapter 717 of the Florida Statutes, the law that sends forgotten money to the state’s unclaimed property program, where owners can still claim it later.

That makes an up-to-date mailing address on the policy the simplest way to make sure the money arrives. Former Infinity customers who have moved since 2025 can contact the company to confirm where a check would be sent.

Florida’s regulator has said more auto insurers are approaching the profit limit. If they cross it, the same law would require them to return the excess to their own policyholders, by check or by credit, on the same 60-day clock.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Michael Rivera – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *