The Apex Building, headquarters of the Federal Trade Commission, in Washington, D.C.
Harrison Keely - CC BY 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

6,789 People Who Paid More Than $899 for a Bogus Health Plan Are Getting a Third FTC Refund Check

Some of the people who went looking for affordable health insurance and ended up paying for a medical discount plan instead are about to get another check in the mail. It is the third one from the same case.

The Federal Trade Commission is sending 6,789 checks totaling more than $266,000 to consumers who bought plans sold by the Consumer Health Benefits Association, according to the agency’s refund page for the case, updated in November 2026. That works out to about $39 per check on average, by The Tonic Edit’s arithmetic.

Who Is Getting This Round

This round is narrow. The FTC says it goes to people who cashed their previous refund check and who paid the Consumer Health Benefits Association more than $899. The checks are paper checks, and the FTC asks recipients to cash them within 90 days.

The agency sent the first refunds in November 2023 and a second round in August 2025. The refund page says those two rounds together returned more than $6.4 million.

What the First Round Paid

When the FTC announced the first round, it said it was sending payments to 47,166 consumers, worth nearly $7 million in all, in a Nov. 6, 2023 release. That averaged roughly $148 per person, by The Tonic Edit’s arithmetic, far more than this third round.

The money came from six final orders the FTC obtained in the case. The 2023 release pointed readers to an interactive FTC dashboard that breaks down refunds by state.

The FTC’s two figures, nearly $7 million announced in 2023 and more than $6.4 million returned across two rounds, are not the same measure: one is what the agency set out to mail, the other what its refund page reports was returned.

What the Company Was Accused Of

According to the FTC’s complaint, the Consumer Health Benefits Association targeted people who were searching online for affordable health insurance. Its telemarketers pitched medical discount plans and, the agency alleged, falsely told buyers that the plans were as widely accepted as health insurance and would deliver the same savings. The FTC also alleged that the company misled people about its refund policies.

The case dates to August 2010, when the FTC and law enforcers in 24 states announced 54 lawsuits and regulatory actions against sellers of medical discount plans, in the agency’s 2010 announcement. The FTC filed three of those cases itself, including the one against the Consumer Health Benefits Association.

In that release, the FTC said the company claimed it worked closely with major medical insurers, that its plan was widely accepted by doctors and pharmacies, that it was accepted wherever Blue Cross Blue Shield was, and that members could save up to 85 percent. Buyers paid $29 to $280 in enrollment fees on top of monthly charges.

David Vladeck, then director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection, said of such plans: “But they are not insurance.” He added that victims “don’t know they’ve been ripped off until after they’ve tried to use the service and paid their bill.” The full case history is on the FTC’s case page.

How to Tell the Check Is Real

Refund checks from old cases are a favorite tool of scammers, who send fake notices asking for a fee or bank details. The FTC’s position is blunt. “The Commission never requires people to pay money or provide account information to get a refund,” the agency said when the first round went out.

The refund administrator for this case is Epiq Systems, which can be reached at 1-888-350-1458. The FTC’s refund program FAQ answers common questions about how the agency’s refund checks and payments work.

Anyone who gets a call, text or email claiming to be from the FTC and asking for money to release a refund can report it. The federal government’s USAGov scam reporting guide walks people through where to file a report based on what kind of scam it was.

Why a Third Check Arrives Years Later

A third round of checks worth about $39 each can look odd years after the first payments. The rule the FTC set for this round explains it: money left in the fund goes back to people who already cashed a check, the group whose mailing addresses are known to work.

The Tonic Edit has tracked several follow-up rounds like this one this fall, including a third round for Ed Napleton Auto Group customers and a second round for Avast customers.

For the 6,789 people on this list, the step is simple: look for the check, confirm it carries the Consumer Health Benefits Association case name, and deposit it before the 90 days run out. A check that looks real but comes with a request for a fee is not from the FTC.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *